Irish Presidency compromise on Clean Corporate Vehicles Regulation would lock EU countries into oil dependency for decades longer than necessary'
At a time when drivers of petrol and diesel cars are being punished by yet another fossil fuel crisis, the Presidency proposes to continue national subsidies for fossil fuel company cars, as long as cleaner vehicles are treated ‘more favourably’. Unless Member States set a clear and ambitious threshold for what that means, this proposal fails to boost demand for clean, Made-in-EU cars, and puts up to 344,000 new EU jobs at risk.
In 2024, an ERM report found that in the five biggest EU economies alone, fossil fuel subsidies for company cars totalled €42 billion. In its proposal for a Regulation on Clean Corporate Vehicles, the European Commission proposed an end to these subsidies from 2028 onwards. The latest compromise by the Irish Presidency would continue subsidies for polluting petrol and diesel corporate cars, on condition that Member States ensure that zero- and low-emission vehicles are treated ‘more favourably’.
The current wording locks in the status quo. Today, some countries already give EVs slightly better tax treatment, but the advantage is far too small to change companies’ choices. Only 9 of 27 Member States give companies enough incentive to electrify, and this proposal is so weak that it would not change that.
That matters well beyond tax policy, T&E warns. The EU imports almost all of its oil and, annually, company cars consume 78% of all of the oil used by new cars. Allowing taxpayer money to continue to subsidise petrol and diesel cars which will leave drivers and companies locked in on expensive and volatile fossil fuels is irresponsible and will keep them exposed to oil price shocks for decades to come, T&E says.
With the compromise proposal, the law would also fail to deliver on one of its core objectives: to boost demand for Made-in-EU electric vehicles. The Commission proposal, combined with Made-In-EU criteria could generate up to 344,000 jobs and 38 billion EUR in investment, much of which would be lost if combustion engine vehicles remain eligible for financial support and no threshold for a ‘more favourable’ treatment is defined.
Ahead of Monday’s Working Party on Land Transport, T&E is calling on Member States to reject the current wording. In 2022, EU countries pledged to end fossil fuel subsidies without delay, so the 2028 phase-out in the Regulation should be restored. At the very minimum, Member States should set a robust and ambitious threshold that ensures a sufficient incentive towards zero-emission vehicles.
Stef Cornelis, Fleets Director at T&E said: “This compromise is a slap in the face of European taxpayers, and risks trapping millions of EU drivers in the oil crisis for another generation. Right when the effect of the Iran war is becoming most acute for families, the Irish Presidency proposes to keep taxpayers’ money feeding oil companies’ surging revenues. If Member States do not come up with a robust and ambitious threshold for more favourable treatment, this compromise locks European drivers into expensive fossil fuels for years to come and puts the jobs and investment this law was meant to deliver on the line.”
Related Articles
View All
Last chance to get it right: The Industrial Accelerator Act will make or break Europe’s battery industry
How the Franco-German auto deal, a wide Made-with-EU scope, and carmakers abandon Europe’s battery value chain to foreign competitors
Almost 90% of Europe’s battery production at risk from Franco-German car deal
Europe has huge potential for battery plants but calls to weaken or delay the Industrial Accelerator Act and carmaker demands to weaken the EU’s CO2 s...
Visual explainer
Electric vehicles, debunked
Myths about EVs run rampant online. We zoomed in on the most common ones to set the record straight.