Blue threat: will the EU's hydrogen policy stay green?
Assessing the new Low-Carbon Fuels Delegated Act and the case for prioritising RFNBO hydrogen
Download documents
Following the recent adoption of the Delegated Act (DA) on low-carbon fuels, the EU has completed the regulatory framework for both renewable (RFNBO) and low-carbon hydrogen production. The worst case scenario has been avoided. The default emissions value for natural gas excludes key segments such as Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) liquefaction, shipping and regasification, that must be calculated separately. Yet, the prescribed emissions values still downplay the real climate impact of blue hydrogen production. The proposed rules rely on outdated methane leakage rates and fail to consider the short-term climate impacts of methane, and leave critical gaps in midstream emissions accounting. Low-carbon electrolysis hydrogen also benefits from looser rules compared to RFNBO hydrogen, creating an uneven playing field. There is a real risk of locking in high-emission hydrogen pathways under the guise of ‘low-carbon’. T&E recommends that the EU: |
-
Ensures strong safeguards for calculating low-carbon hydrogen emissions: Ensure full lifecycle GHG accounting of natural gas, including an assessment of upstream methane leakage and midstream emissions as well as considering the higher short-term climate impacts of methane.
-
Maintains regulatory stability : Do not reopen and weaken the GHG methodology for RFNBO rules. With both RFNBO and low-carbon hydrogen methodologies now defined, investors need regulatory stability to move projects to Final Investment Decisions.
-
Focuses on supporting first-of-a-kind projects: Keep the focus on enabling Final Investment Decisions for RFNBO projects, and support long-term offtake agreements for airlines and shipping companies to ensure e-fuels can meet FuelEU and ReFuel targets, through financial mechanisms such as European Hydrogen Clearing House.
Related Articles
View All
150 new power plants: the cost of balancing the grid if the EU slashes EV targets
Scaling back the EU’s electric car targets makes the transition to renewables far more expensive to achieve.
Weakening CO₂ standards undermines the Vehicle-to-Grid potential of EVs
A new report by Fraunhofer ISI examines the diminished benefits of V2G for Europe's electricity system if the EU weakens its car CO2 targets.
Global biofuel demand set to grow by nearly 70% as food prices rise
High biofuels targets will exacerbate rising global food prices, as well as fertilisers shortages