Press Release

EU energy ministers reject a bad deal on biofuels but status quo is even worse

December 12, 2013

European energy ministers today rejected by a blocking minority a political deal to amend the EU biofuels policy. The rejected agreement, struck by the Lithuanian Presidency of the EU, would have limited the use of food-based biofuels that are eligible to count towards carbon reduction targets [1] to 7% of transport fuel – a cap close to the original 2020 target. The deal would have also mandated just the reporting of biofuel emissions from indirect land-use change (ILUC) [2] with a wide range of values for ILUC factors.

Belgium, Denmark, the Netherlands, Italy and Luxembourg, which held the most progressive positions in the Council, rejected the compromise because they thought it was too weak. Poland and Hungary, to the contrary, rejected it because they wanted no limits on the uptake of conventional biofuels.
Reacting to the decision, T&E’s clean fuels manager, Nusa Urbancic, said: “The compromise on the table was ugly, but the status quo is even worse. Ministers should listen to the progressive countries and adopt a position closer to that of the Parliament. Failure to act means more emissions and higher costs; it is difficult to see why Europe would want that.” [3]
The proposed and rejected 7% cap would have led to a one-off release of 400 million tonnes of CO2 compared to the 5% cap proposed by the Commission [4]. This is equivalent to adding nine million extra cars to Europe’s roads by 2020. The mere reporting of ILUC emissions would have allowed biofuels that produce more emissions than conventional diesel and petrol to still count towards the 10% renewable energy target in transport by 2020.
Now, the incoming Greek Presidency of the EU will resume political negotiations to reach a new agreement before the second-reading negotiations with the Parliament can start.

Related Articles

View All
Chapter 3.png
Letter

Joint letter calling on removing Dieselgate cars

Joint letter for the 'roadworthiness package' to deliver on the removal of Dieselgate cars from EU roads

A coalition of signatories ask for fixes or scrappage of high-emitting cars at the expense of manufacturers

Press Release

10 years after Dieselgate, another scandal comes

10 years after Dieselgate, the car industry is paving the way for another emissions scandal

Manufacturers want to kill off EU rules that would better reflect pollution from plug-in hybrid vehicles

Press Release

Plug-in hybrids now emit five times, on average, what official tests claim – EU data

But the car lobby is demanding that the EU scrap rules that would better reflect PHEV pollution.