3-5% points of global warming could be freed up by implementing contrail avoidance
A policy roadmap for aviation non-CO2 emissions in Europe
There is no single silver bullet for the mitigation of aviation non-CO2 emissions, and will need to be addressed through a combination of policies. While EU law includes sporadic initiatives on non-CO2 emissions, a coherent vision and holistic approach for their reduction is lacking.
3% Less than 3% of flights generate 80% of contrail induced waming globally.
Read the full report
Author
Aviation's total environmental footprint is the sum of its CO2 and non-CO2 impacts combined. While the EU claims to be seriously committed to addressing the full climate impact of the sector, regulation of and action on non-CO2 emissions is lagging behind.
We have reached the point where science - at least for certain non-CO2 forcers - is sufficiently robust, so that the EU can complement research with regulation and start gradually rolling out mitigation solutions. Further delay in taking action can’t be justified under the precautionary principle. Evidence shows that even if the mitigation strategy is not perfect at first, the most significant climate risk can be inaction.
Addressing non-CO2 emissions is necessary to stay on track with the Paris commitment
Mitigating non-CO2 emissions is not only an opportunity for the aviation sector to reduce its environmental footprint in the short-term, but recent scientific research confirms that it is vital to stay on track with the temperature goal of the Paris Agreement. CO2 net zero efforts are crucial, but alone won’t be sufficient to achieve the targets.
A three-pronged problem: climate, air quality and health
Beyond their climate impact, non-CO2 emissions have an adverse effect on air quality and people’s health, especially in communities living nearby a major airport. An estimated 50 million people living around the 32 major airports in Europe could experience significant health effects like high blood pressure, diabetes and dementia as a result of ultra fine particles released by aircraft. Addressing those pollutants through changes in jet fuel composition can lead to a double benefit: climate and health.
Solutions exist but need policy support to scale up
Mitigation solutions exist, but they can’t be scaled up without a favourable regulatory framework. The necessary investments in operationalising contrail avoidance at scale or in R&D - such as developing and deploying tools for air traffic controllers to re-route aircraft for contrail-avoidance or further research into how changes in jet fuel composition can improve air quality - won’t be realized without the necessary certainty for stakeholders.
This is why T&E has developed a vision on how combining different policies can enable the scale up of mitigation solutions. In developing this Roadmap, T&E has conducted a series of interviews with various stakeholder groups, such as airlines, Air Navigation Service Providers (ANSPs), policy makers, scientists and NGOs.
Key recommendations
Addressing aviation non-CO2 emissions requires EU action in five different policy areas:
-
1
Integrating non-CO2 emissions into EU climate targets. The European Climate Law enshrines an economy-wide net zero target by 2050 but restricts its scope to Kyoto-listed greenhouse gases, omitting aviation non-CO₂ emissions. Guided by the precautionary principle, and building on the best available science, the EU must include contrails and non-CO₂ greenhouse gas emissions in climate targets in a phased-in manner, starting with the acknowledgement of the need to address them.
-
2
Integrating contrails into the EU ETS. To effectively monitor non-CO₂ emissions and incentivise mitigation for airlines, it is crucial to proceed with the automatic extension of the EU’s monitoring and verification tool (the non-CO₂ MRV) to all departing and incoming flights. This would ensure the most warming long-haul flights are in scope and thus inform policy making. In addition, the European Commission’s proposed incentive scheme (“contrail allowances”) in the EU ETS is a positive step enabling airlines to take action on contrail avoidance. An effective incentive scheme should support contrail avoidance planning systems and the cost of executing contrail avoidance. In line with the MRV, the scheme should cover all flights arriving to and departing from Europe, and the support should be tailored to match the latest scientific insights on the cost of contrail avoidance.
-
3
Integrating contrail avoidance in European air traffic management. Navigational contrail avoidance - re-routing flights to avoid the cold and humid airspaces prone to contrail-forming - is among the fastest and most affordable ways for the sector to mitigate its environmental footprint. In order to scale it up, Europe needs to: 1) Secure funding for medium and large-scale trials, with particular focus on combined trials, in the upcoming Aviation Strategy and in the next Multi-Annual Financial Framework (MFF) via initiatives such as the proposed Clean Aviation Moonshot. 2) Prioritize R&D for deployment of contrail avoidance with particular focus on ATM tooling. 3) Enable European ATM legislation for contrail avoidance. This includes a new Environmental and Climate KPI for Air Navigation Service Providers (ANSPs) that allows for contrail avoidance and expanding the mandate of the Network Manager to include contrail avoidance coordination.
-
4
Integrating non-CO2 emissions into RefuelEU. Changing jet fuel composition is a powerful but currently unused lever to improve air quality, and reduce health and climate impacts of aviation non-CO2 emissions. As jet fuel remains the main source of fuel for aircraft for the next two decades, the EU should introduce a jet fuel specification as part of the RefuelEU review in 2027 and gradually lower the level of pollutants in the subsequent reviews.
-
5
Supporting non-CO2 mitigation with aircraft technology. On top of contributing to decarbonisation, disruptive aircraft technologies, such as zero-emission and hybrid propulsion systems, also reduce aviation’s non-CO2 emissions. Therefore, public support for aviation R&D in the next MFF should move from incremental improvements to high risk, high reward technologies that mitigate both carbon and non-CO2 emissions. The EU should also leverage existing aviation legislation, such as the EU ETS, ReFuelEU or the Air Services Regulation, to create the right market conditions for disruptive aircraft technologies. Finally, NOx, vPM and nvPM engine emission standards should be strengthened, including the creation of a standard for cruise emissions.
Related Articles
View All
Court ruling opens door for stronger action on aviation’s climate impacts
European Court of Justice ruling paves way for governments to reduce slots at airports and use slot allocation as a strategic tool in addressing aviat...
Tackling contrails could avoid 10 years of aviation-related climate warming - new research
A way forward for contrail mitigation
T&E briefing on Klima Consulting’s review of the science and technology of contrail mitigation